Sorting through the belongings inherited from family members can be a nostalgic yet overwhelming experience. Recently, while exploring a collection of boxes left behind by my late grandparents, I stumbled upon a box enigmatically labeled “toothpick holders and other treasures.” Despite the promise of unique keepsakes, the box did not contain toothpick holders; instead, it was filled with various mementos, including a solitary jigsaw puzzle piece. This piece served as a poignant reminder of my grandmother’s playful habit of hiding the last puzzle piece, only to reveal it at the last moment. As my mother and I spent hours sifting through the items, we found ourselves pondering the inevitable question: “Why do we keep these things?”
This question resonates deeply within my practice as a licensed clinical psychologist focusing on hoarding disorder, especially among older adults. Hoarding disorder is characterized by excessive accumulation of items, stemming from a profound difficulty discarding possessions. For many individuals, this inclination manifests as a form of emotional attachment where the act of saving items becomes intertwined with sentimentality and identity.
The Nature of Hoarding and Sentimentality
Hoarding behavior can impact one’s daily functioning, creating conditions within a home that can be hazardous. However, in my clinical experience, numerous older adults grapple with clutter yet do not meet the strict criteria for hoarding disorder. This observation has led me to consider how our perspectives on possessions evolve as we age. With time, we naturally accumulate objects that hold sentimental value or that we deem useful, but for some, this behavior escalates into a compulsive need to keep everything.
Research suggests that cognitive changes associated with aging, particularly alterations in executive function, may contribute to the increase of hoarding behaviors among this demographic. Problematic decision-making can complicate one’s ability to discern which items are genuinely valuable and which should be discarded. However, my own research challenges the notion that distress during decision-making is a uniform experience among older adults.
Redefining the Decision-Making Process
In a study I conducted as a graduate student, participants diagnosed with hoarding disorder were asked to categorize various items from their homes. Surprisingly, older participants reported significantly less distress during this process than their younger counterparts. Many even expressed positive feelings while sorting through their belongings, suggesting that the emotional weight typically associated with discarding items is not universally experienced.
My recent studies indicate that rather than fear of making mistakes, older adults often hold onto items for altruistic reasons. For instance, individuals commonly articulate a desire to pass along items to others to ensure they are valued, stating thoughts like, “I need it to go to a good home.” This reveals a deep-rooted sense of responsibility towards possessions—a sentiment that aligns with personal values rather than anxiety about loss.
A 2024 study I co-authored highlighted the efficacy of a values-oriented approach to decluttering. During this project, clinicians employed motivational interviewing techniques to help older adults articulate their values while sorting through clutter. This method empowered participants to align their decisions with their personal beliefs and long-term goals. Focusing on values opens pathways for a more profound understanding of what items are essential or meaningful, encouraging a more rational, less emotional State of decision-making.
In our findings, rather than centering on immediate gratification from objects—what some might refer to as “sparks of joy”—we discovered that recognizing deeper significance often leads to more significant emotional satisfaction. Values, which differ vastly among individuals, illuminate what possessions should remain in one’s space. For instance, one might choose to keep a family heirloom due to its sentimental worth while another might prioritize decluttering with practicality in mind, thus letting go of the same item.
Drawing from what I’ve gathered through clinical trials and personal observations, I recommend several practical steps that can assist individuals of all ages in tackling clutter:
1. **Identify Your Values**: List your core beliefs and life priorities. This creates a lens through which to view your possessions and guides your decision-making process.
2. **Define Goals for Your Space**: Whether you’re clearing your desk for effective work or making room for family gatherings, clarity around your intentions can motivate the decluttering process.
3. **Embrace Subjectivity**: Understand that each person’s assessment of what to keep is inherently subjective. The attachment others have to items may not align with your perspectives.
4. **Practice Non-Judgment**: If you are assisting someone else in decluttering, maintain an open, curious mindset. What may seem trivial to you could hold deep significance for them.
5. **Reflect on Conflicts**: Acknowledge that your values can sometimes oppose one another. During such times, consider whether keeping or discarding an item aligns with your ultimate life goals.
The relationship between clutter and personal values is intricate and deeply entwined with our identities and experiences. Understanding this connection can aid in fostering emotional well-being and lead to a more meaningful interaction with our possessions. For further insights, resources are available through organizations like the International OCD Foundation.
Leave a Reply